Introduction - Civil liberties for immigrants
Point: immigrants' civil rights are being ignored after 9/11
Counterpoint: immigrants should not be afforded all protections as citizens at the expense of national security
Point: detention of immigrants indefinitely violates the constitution
Counterpoint: indefinite detention of immigrants does not raise a constitutional concern
Point: a fundamental first amendment right of access to information exists in immigration proceedings in the wake of 9/11
Counterpoint: national security requires immigration proceedings to be closed
